Archived copy of the old Interstate Outlaws website (read-only). Logins, posting, search and member profiles are gone. · Archive home · btoutlaws.com

Forum index » Feedback

Feedback and questions · and stats...

jabb
Feb 03 2008, 16:08 UTC
 
I should start with feedback:

1. Without any enemies the game is not fun at all. It's obvious.
2. Physics are pretty decent, but cars feel too 'nervous' especially when driving on bumpy parts of terrain.
3. Game is very heavy on CPU even when only game menu is shown.
4. Load times are extremely long given the size of textures and complexity of models.
5. I can't seem to be using my gamepad.
6. celstart_static.exe gets nearly 170MB of RAM when I watch the car in garage! Second time I enter - 210MB, third time 250MB!
7. Ground is black near camera, normal in distance.

Suggestions:

1. Front wheels should straighten up faster, maybe it could be adjustable in options - it will give more control over the car's behaviour.
2. You should be able to map controls to your own choice of keys.
3. Exhaust particles should grow and fade, not simply move and magically disappear.
4. Strider could get some darker shader.

Questions:

1. What's the desirable polycount for car models? *
2. What software do you use to create 3D content? *
3. How to set up joystick to use it in this game?


(*) I am a 3D modeler and I'd like to contribute to the project but I don't know where to aim with my works. I'm a Blender user so my exporting possibilities are limited.

<Windows XP, HP dc7600 P4 3GHz, 512MB RAM, Intel 82945G Express (Integrated)>
Performance @ 1024x768, non-fullscreen:
Menu - 55-60FPS
Garage - 10FPS
Game (with hud) - 12FPS
Game (without hud) - 18FPS
Tom
Feb 03 2008, 18:02 UTC
 
Have you read this yet?
jabb
Feb 03 2008, 18:14 UTC
 
Nah. I just thought I must do something to waste your time and make you guys angry. sleep.gif


Of course I did and I understand every single word of it. I'm just trying to be helpful and share my opinion with you.
If you don't need it - please just answer my questions.
R5
Feb 03 2008, 18:26 UTC
 
I think a lot of your problem is your video card. You can't expect to run the latest and greatest with an onboard card. That card is known to have pretty low FPS in halflife 2, and that game is already getting old. That said, we know that what we have currently probably isn't 100% efficient.

I think the CPU and memory issues are addressed in the link Tom gave you.

I think I'll let Cfraz answer the remainder of your concerns.

Thanks for the feedback!
R5
Feb 04 2008, 16:06 UTC
 
Alright, I guess Cfraz doesn't have enough time right now. Let me go through your concerns.

QUOTE
1. Without any enemies the game is not fun at all. It's obvious.

It's designed to be a multiplayer game. Any single player that we create is purely a secondary priority. That said, we have programmed AI. Last I checked, you can fight them in Melee mode, but Cfraz may have disabled that.

QUOTE
2. Physics are pretty decent, but cars feel too 'nervous' especially when driving on bumpy parts of terrain.

Well, we're working on the physics. It will improve with time. Unfortunately, no matter how we do it, somebody isn't going to like exactly how it handles. Sorry.

QUOTE
3. Game is very heavy on CPU even when only game menu is shown.
4. Load times are extremely long given the size of textures and complexity of models.


I think Tom and I addressed that already.

QUOTE
5. I can't seem to be using my gamepad.

We'll support joysticks and gamepads eventually. We're currently looking for programmers, so if you know any who might be interested, have them post in the "Join the Team" forum.

QUOTE
6. celstart_static.exe gets nearly 170MB of RAM when I watch the car in garage! Second time I enter - 210MB, third time 250MB!
7. Ground is black near camera, normal in distance.


I believe these are also discussed in the aforementioned post.

QUOTE
1. Front wheels should straighten up faster, maybe it could be adjustable in options - it will give more control over the car's behaviour.

2. You should be able to map controls to your own choice of keys.

We agree with these statements. It's something we've been meaning to get around to.

QUOTE
3. Exhaust particles should grow and fade, not simply move and magically disappear.

This might be an issue with your video card. That said, we could have particles hang around longer -- but then again, that would lower your FPS even more.

QUOTE
4. Strider could get some darker shader.

The Strider isn't even supposed to be a part of the game. It's an old model that was made for the Interstate Outlaws MOD for Interstate '82. It's getting yanked from the game soon -- probably with the next update or two.

We appreciate your feedback very much. Please don't let these answers discourage you from providing us with further feedback. You have to understand that we are a very small team and have limited resources and time to devote to everything. As a result, progress is slow. If you're a modeler, please post in the "Join the Team" forum with some examples of your work. Thanks!!

R5
jabb
Feb 06 2008, 19:16 UTC
 
I've tried to test the program on a different computer so I set up a DELL GX240, 1.6GHz, 1GB RAM, 128MB GeForce FX5200, Windows 2000 SP4. Game starts, menu appears, garage loads nicely and everything seems to be fine until I actually want to try regular game - the main window crashes leaving only console visible and Windows reports a crash.
Other than that - loading screen is at ~150FPS, menu is over 200FPS, garage shows a ~20FPS and before game breaks down after I press 'Play' it's jumping form 10 to 20FPS.

EDIT: Forgot to change name. I've changed it once before but it didn't seem to save. Will check that.

EDIT2: Checked. Game started nicely but crashed a while later when I started shooting. Looks same as before with Windows crash report just this time I got 2 of those. :/
cfraz89
Feb 08 2008, 01:18 UTC
 
Hi jabb, looks like your not having much luck with this. Does it always crash when you start shooting?
jabb
Feb 08 2008, 08:38 UTC
 
I've tried it again after restarting my computer once more and it worked nicely. Seems like it was just some random failure that I can't reproduce anymore.

I can really say now that the game looks pretty cool and despite quite unbalanced physics it probably will be fun in Multi Melee.



Just another thing I spotted - flamethrower - flame particles shot by this weapon move like their velocities are relative not to the world but to the vehicle itself - it gives a very strange feeling when you use flamethrower while turning. Particles disappear instantly when button is not pressed.

Oh... and game seems to work only with Python 2.4 for me, because when I removed 2.4 and 2.5 and then reinstalled 2.5 it crashed every time.
TaMaX
Feb 21 2008, 20:48 UTC
 
I can add a gamePad support tongue.gif